▼ 1st
Jim Gentile out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Earl Robinson scores. Boog Powell to 2nd.
0–1
▲ 4th
Elston Howard singles on a to left fielder Boog Powell. Tom Tresh scores. Mickey Mantle to 2nd.
1–1
▲ 4th
Bill Skowron singles on a ground ball to center fielder Jackie Brandt. Mickey Mantle scores. Elston Howard out at home on the throw, center fielder Jackie Brandt to third baseman Brooks Robinson to catcher Gus Triandos to third baseman Brooks Robinson.
2–1
▼ 4th
Gus Triandos hits a home run (2).
2–2
▲ 5th
Clete Boyer hits a home run (2).
3–2
▼ 5th
Earl Robinson doubles (1) on a ground ball to right fielder Roger Maris. Johnny Temple scores.
3–3
▲ 7th
Bill Skowron hits a home run (2).
4–3
▲ 7th
Bobby Richardson doubles (1) on a to left fielder Boog Powell. Clete Boyer scores.
5–3
▲ 8th
Elston Howard singles on a to right fielder Earl Robinson. Mickey Mantle scores. Jack Reed to 3rd.
6–3
▲ 8th
Bill Skowron reaches on a fielder's choice, fielded by shortstop Jerry Adair. Jack Reed scores. Elston Howard to 2nd.
7–3
▲ 8th
Clete Boyer doubles (2). Elston Howard scores. Bill Skowron to 3rd.
8–3