▲ 1st
Gene Stephens hits a home run (1).
1–0
▼ 2nd
Elston Howard reaches on a fielding error by center fielder Gene Stephens. Mickey Mantle scores.
1–1
▼ 3rd
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (16). Tony Kubek scores. Roger Maris scores.
1–4
▲ 4th
Leo Posada out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Gene Stephens scores. Norm Siebern to 3rd.
2–4
▲ 4th
Reno Bertoia singles on a to left fielder Yogi Berra. Norm Siebern scores.
3–4
▼ 5th
Mickey Mantle singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Tony Kubek scores.
3–5
▲ 6th
Leo Posada hits a home run (4). Norm Siebern scores.
5–5
▼ 7th
Roger Maris hits a home run (18). Tony Kubek scores.
5–7
▼ 8th
Clete Boyer out, third baseman Andy Carey to first baseman Norm Siebern. Bobby Richardson scores.
5–8
▲ 9th
Don Larsen singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Andy Carey scores.
6–8