▲ 1st
Bill Skowron singles on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Mickey Mantle scores. Roger Maris to 3rd.
1–0
▼ 2nd
Pete Daley out, second baseman Gil McDougald to first baseman Bill Skowron. Dick Williams scores.
1–1
▲ 3rd
Roger Maris hits a home run (34). Tony Kubek scores.
3–1
▼ 3rd
Bill Tuttle hits a home run (4).
3–2
▲ 4th
Clete Boyer doubles (13) on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Bob Cerv scores. Clete Boyer to 3rd.
4–2
▲ 4th
Bill Short doubles (1) on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Clete Boyer scores.
5–2
▲ 4th
Tony Kubek singles on a line drive to right fielder Hank Bauer. Bill Short scores. Tony Kubek to 2nd.
6–2
▲ 4th
Mickey Mantle singles on a line drive to right fielder Hank Bauer. Tony Kubek scores.
7–2
▲ 5th
Bob Cerv doubles (4) on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Bill Skowron scores. Johnny Blanchard to 3rd.
8–2
▲ 5th
Bill Short grounds into a force out, fielded by second baseman Jerry Lumpe. Johnny Blanchard scores. Bob Cerv to 3rd. Clete Boyer out at 2nd. Bill Short to 1st.
9–2
▲ 5th
Gil McDougald out on a sacrifice bunt to first baseman Dick Williams. Bob Cerv scores. Bill Short to 2nd.
10–2
▲ 5th
Tony Kubek singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Bill Short scores.
11–2
▲ 5th
Roger Maris hits a home run (35). Tony Kubek scores. Mickey Mantle scores.
14–2
▼ 5th
Bill Tuttle hits a home run (5).
14–3
▲ 7th
Roger Maris out on a sacrifice fly to right fielder Russ Snyder. Tony Kubek scores. Mickey Mantle to 3rd.
15–3
▼ 7th
Russ Snyder singles on a ground ball to center fielder Tony Kubek. Jerry Lumpe scores.
15–4
▲ 8th
Clete Boyer singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Bob Cerv scores.
16–4