▲ 1st
Gil McDougald walks. Hector Lopez scores. Roger Maris to 3rd. Bill Skowron to 2nd.
1–0
▼ 2nd
John Romano hits a home run (10).
1–1
▲ 4th
Clete Boyer out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Tito Francona. Elston Howard scores. Bobby Richardson to 3rd.
2–1
▲ 4th
Hector Lopez grounds into a force out, pitcher Dick Stigman to shortstop George Strickland. Bobby Richardson scores. Whitey Ford out at 2nd. Hector Lopez to 1st.
3–1
▲ 4th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (22). Hector Lopez scores. Roger Maris scores.
6–1
▼ 4th
John Romano out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Hector Lopez. Ken Aspromonte scores.
6–2
▲ 8th
Clete Boyer singles on a to center fielder Jim Piersall. Bobby Richardson scores. Clete Boyer to 2nd.
7–2
▲ 9th
Roger Maris hits a home run (29).
8–2
▲ 9th
Elston Howard singles on a ground ball to center fielder Jim Piersall. Mickey Mantle scores.
9–2