▲ 1st
Bill Skowron singles on a ground ball to right fielder Al Smith. Tony Kubek scores.
1–0
▲ 2nd
Roger Maris hits a home run (5).
2–0
▲ 2nd
Gil McDougald hits a home run (4).
3–0
▼ 2nd
Billy Goodman out, shortstop Tony Kubek to first baseman Bill Skowron. Sherm Lollar scores.
3–1
▼ 2nd
Earl Torgeson out, second baseman Bobby Richardson to first baseman Bill Skowron. Al Smith scores. Jim Landis to 3rd.
3–2
▼ 2nd
Luis Aparicio singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Jim Landis scores.
3–3
▲ 3rd
Bob Cerv hits a home run (7).
4–3
▼ 3rd
Ted Kluszewski doubles (4) on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Minnie Minoso scores.
4–4
▼ 3rd
Billy Goodman singles on a to shortstop Tony Kubek. Ted Kluszewski scores. Al Smith to 2nd.
4–5
▼ 4th
Sherm Lollar out on a sacrifice fly to right fielder Roger Maris. Minnie Minoso scores.
4–6
▼ 5th
Luis Aparicio out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Sammy Esposito scores. Jim Landis to 3rd.
4–7
▼ 5th
Nellie Fox singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Jim Landis scores.
4–8
▲ 6th
Tony Kubek doubles (8) on a to right fielder Al Smith. Roger Maris scores. Gil McDougald scores.
6–8
▲ 7th
Roger Maris hits a home run (6). Elston Howard scores.
8–8
▼ 7th
Minnie Minoso singles on a to right fielder Roger Maris. Luis Aparicio scores. Minnie Minoso to 2nd.
8–9