▼ 1st
Roger Maris singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Gil McDougald scores. Mickey Mantle to 3rd. Roger Maris to 2nd. Throwing error by center fielder Bill Tuttle.
0–1
▼ 1st
Elston Howard singles on a to left fielder Bob Cerv. Mickey Mantle scores. Roger Maris scores.
0–3
▲ 2nd
Norm Siebern hits a home run (5).
1–3
▼ 2nd
Tony Kubek doubles (4) on a to right fielder Whitey Herzog. Bobby Richardson scores.
1–4
▼ 3rd
Bill Skowron doubles (5) on a to right fielder Whitey Herzog. Roger Maris scores.
1–5
▲ 4th
Marv Throneberry walks. Bob Cerv scores. Dick Williams to 3rd. Harry Chiti to 2nd.
2–5
▲ 4th
Jerry Lumpe singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Dick Williams scores. Harry Chiti to 3rd. Marv Throneberry to 2nd.
3–5
▲ 4th
Whitey Herzog walks. Harry Chiti scores. Marv Throneberry to 3rd. Jerry Lumpe to 2nd.
4–5
▲ 6th
Hank Bauer singles on a ground ball to left fielder Ken Hunt. Bill Tuttle scores. Jerry Lumpe to 3rd.
5–5
▲ 6th
Norm Siebern doubles (3) on a to right fielder Roger Maris. Jerry Lumpe scores. Hank Bauer to 3rd.
6–5
▲ 6th
Bob Cerv out on a sacrifice fly to right fielder Roger Maris. Hank Bauer scores. Norm Siebern to 3rd.
7–5
▼ 7th
Roger Maris doubles (6) on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Gil McDougald scores.
7–6
▼ 7th
Elston Howard singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Roger Maris scores.
7–7
▼ 8th
Gil McDougald singles on a to left fielder Bob Cerv. Bobby Richardson scores.
7–8