▲ 1st
Elston Howard singles on a ground ball to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Tony Kubek scores. Mickey Mantle scores. Yogi Berra to 2nd.
2–0
▼ 2nd
Kent Hadley singles on a ground ball to right fielder Yogi Berra. Bob Cerv scores. Jerry Lumpe scores. Kent Hadley to 3rd. Fielding error by right fielder Yogi Berra.
2–2
▼ 2nd
Frank House out, second baseman Bobby Richardson to first baseman Marv Throneberry. Kent Hadley scores.
2–3
▲ 3rd
Hector Lopez hits a home run (18). Mickey Mantle scores.
4–3
▲ 4th
Bobby Richardson singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Clete Boyer scores.
5–3
▼ 4th
Bill Tuttle singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Frank House scores. Joe Morgan to 2nd.
5–4
▼ 5th
Dick Williams hits a home run (13).
5–5
▲ 6th
Yogi Berra singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Bobby Richardson scores. Tony Kubek scores. Mickey Mantle to 2nd.
7–5
▲ 6th
Hector Lopez hits into a double play, third baseman Dick Williams to first baseman Kent Hadley to shortstop Jerry Lumpe. Mickey Mantle scores. Elston Howard out at 3rd.
8–5
▼ 7th
Kent Hadley doubles (10) on a to left fielder Hector Lopez. Jerry Lumpe scores. Kent Hadley to 3rd.
8–6
▲ 9th
Clete Boyer out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Elston Howard scores.
9–6
▼ 9th
Kent Hadley singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Dick Williams scores. Bob Cerv to 2nd.
9–7