▲ 1st
Hal Smith hits a ground-rule double (11) on a . Roger Maris scores. Bob Cerv scores. Harry Simpson to 3rd.
2–0
▲ 1st
Harry Chiti singles on a ground ball to left fielder Norm Siebern. Harry Simpson scores. Hal Smith scores.
4–0
▲ 1st
Ralph Terry singles on a ground ball to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Harry Chiti scores. Joe Demaestri to 2nd.
5–0
▲ 1st
Bob Martyn triples (7) on a to right fielder Yogi Berra. Joe Demaestri scores. Ralph Terry scores.
7–0
▼ 2nd
Andy Carey triples (4) on a to center fielder Roger Maris. Elston Howard scores.
7–1
▼ 2nd
Bobby Richardson singles on a bunt ground ball to pitcher Ralph Terry. Andy Carey scores.
7–2
▼ 3rd
Yogi Berra hits a home run (20). Norm Siebern scores.
7–4
▲ 4th
Bob Cerv singles on a ground ball to right fielder Yogi Berra. Hector Lopez scores.
8–4
▲ 4th
Hal Smith singles on a to right fielder Yogi Berra. Bob Cerv scores. Harry Simpson to 2nd.
9–4
▲ 5th
Hector Lopez singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Tom Gorman scores.
10–4
▼ 7th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (37). Marv Throneberry scores. Tony Kubek scores.
10–7
▲ 8th
Joe Demaestri singles on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Hal Smith scores. Harry Chiti to 3rd.
11–7