▲ 1st
Bob Nieman reaches on a fielding error by third baseman Jerry Lumpe. Jim Busby scores. Bob Boyd to 3rd.
1–0
▲ 1st
Gene Woodling singles on a to right fielder Enos Slaughter. Bob Boyd scores. Bob Nieman to 2nd.
2–0
▲ 1st
Brooks Robinson singles on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Bob Nieman scores. Gene Woodling scores. Gus Triandos to 2nd.
4–0
▲ 1st
Foster Castleman grounds into a double play, shortstop Tony Kubek to second baseman Gil McDougald to first baseman Elston Howard. Gus Triandos scores. Brooks Robinson to 3rd. Billy Gardner out at 2nd. Foster Castleman out at 1st.
5–0
▼ 1st
Yogi Berra singles on a to second baseman Billy Gardner. Gil McDougald scores.
5–1
▲ 5th
Gene Woodling hits a home run (9).
6–1
▼ 5th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (32). Tony Kubek scores.
6–3
▲ 7th
Gene Woodling singles on a to right fielder Enos Slaughter. Bob Boyd scores. Bob Nieman to 3rd.
7–3
▲ 7th
Gus Triandos out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Bob Nieman scores.
8–3
▲ 9th
Gus Triandos grounds into a double play, third baseman Jerry Lumpe to second baseman Gil McDougald to first baseman Elston Howard. Dick Williams scores. Al Pilarcik out at 2nd. Gus Triandos out at 1st.
9–3