▲ 1st
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (27).
1–0
▼ 1st
Bob Cerv hits a home run (27). Roger Maris scores.
1–2
▲ 4th
Andy Carey singles on a to left fielder Bob Cerv. Mickey Mantle scores. Elston Howard to 3rd.
2–2
▲ 4th
Tony Kubek reaches on a fielder's choice, fielded by second baseman Hector Lopez. Elston Howard scores. Andy Carey to 3rd. Norm Siebern to 2nd. Missed catch error by shortstop Joe Demaestri, assist to second baseman Hector Lopez.
3–2
▲ 4th
Hank Bauer triples (5) on a to right fielder Roger Maris. Andy Carey scores. Norm Siebern scores. Tony Kubek scores. Hank Bauer out at home on the throw, right fielder Roger Maris to shortstop Joe Demaestri to catcher Hal Smith.
6–2
▼ 4th
Hal Smith hits a home run (3).
6–3
▲ 5th
Elston Howard singles. Mickey Mantle scores. Bill Skowron scores.
8–3
▲ 5th
Tony Kubek grounds into a force out, shortstop Joe Demaestri to second baseman Hector Lopez. Elston Howard scores. Andy Carey to 3rd. Norm Siebern out at 2nd. Tony Kubek to 1st.
9–3
▼ 5th
Chico Carrasquel out, shortstop Tony Kubek to first baseman Bill Skowron. Bob Martyn scores.
9–4
▲ 6th
Gil McDougald hits a home run (9). Hank Bauer scores.
11–4
▲ 6th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (28).
12–4
▼ 6th
Bob Cerv hits a home run (28).
12–5
▼ 6th
Whitey Herzog reaches on a fielding error by first baseman Bill Skowron. Preston Ward scores. Hector Lopez scores.
12–7
▲ 8th
Gil McDougald hits a home run (10).
13–7
▲ 9th
Hank Bauer doubles (16). Norm Siebern scores.
14–7