▲ 1st
Gil McDougald hits a home run (6). Hank Bauer scores.
2–0
▲ 3rd
Jerry Lumpe doubles (2) on a to left fielder Gus Zernial. Gil McDougald scores.
3–0
▲ 3rd
Norm Siebern out, second baseman Frank Bolling to first baseman Gail Harris. Jerry Lumpe scores. Yogi Berra to 2nd.
4–0
▲ 4th
Hank Bauer singles on a to left fielder Gus Zernial. Tony Kubek scores.
5–0
▲ 5th
Norm Siebern hits a home run (8). Jerry Lumpe scores.
7–0
▼ 5th
Harvey Kuenn grounds into a force out, shortstop Tony Kubek to second baseman Gil McDougald. Ozzie Virgil scores. Bob Hazle out at 2nd. Harvey Kuenn to 1st.
7–1
▲ 6th
Gil McDougald caught stealing 2nd base, catcher Jim Hegan to shortstop Billy Martin to first baseman Gail Harris to catcher Jim Hegan to third baseman Ozzie Virgil. Hank Bauer scores. Missed catch error by catcher Jim Hegan, assist to third baseman Ozzie Virgil.
8–1
▲ 6th
Wild pitch by pitcher Bill Fischer. Jerry Lumpe scores. Yogi Berra to 2nd.
9–1
▲ 6th
Elston Howard singles on a ground ball to left fielder Gus Zernial. Yogi Berra scores. Norm Siebern to 2nd.
10–1
▲ 6th
Bill Skowron doubles (14) on a to center fielder Harvey Kuenn. Norm Siebern scores. Elston Howard to 3rd.
11–1
▲ 6th
Tony Kubek singles on a ground ball to center fielder Harvey Kuenn. Elston Howard scores. Bill Skowron scores.
13–1
▼ 9th
Gus Zernial hits a home run (5).
13–2
▼ 9th
Tito Francona doubles (6) on a to center fielder Norm Siebern. Frank Bolling scores.
13–3