▲ 1st
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (14). Elston Howard scores.
2–0
▲ 3rd
Bill Skowron walks.
3–0
▲ 3rd
Yogi Berra singles on a ground ball to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Gil McDougald scores. Bill Skowron to 3rd.
4–0
▲ 3rd
Norm Siebern out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Bob Cerv. Bill Skowron scores.
5–0
▼ 4th
Hector Lopez hits a home run (8). Roger Maris scores.
5–2
▼ 4th
Joe Demaestri singles on a ground ball to left fielder Norm Siebern. Harry Simpson scores. Frank House to 2nd.
5–3
▲ 5th
Andy Carey grounds into a force out, shortstop Joe Demaestri to second baseman Hector Lopez. Bill Skowron scores. Yogi Berra out at 2nd. Andy Carey to 1st.
6–3
▼ 5th
Harry Simpson singles on a ground ball to right fielder Elston Howard. Roger Maris scores. Bob Cerv scores. Hector Lopez to 3rd.
6–5
▼ 5th
Harry Chiti out, pitcher Bobby Shantz to second baseman Gil McDougald to first baseman Bill Skowron. Hector Lopez scores. Harry Simpson to 2nd.
6–6
▼ 6th
Roger Maris hits a home run (11).
6–7
▼ 6th
Harry Simpson singles on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Preston Ward scores. Bob Cerv to 3rd. Hector Lopez to 2nd.
6–8
▼ 7th
Roger Maris singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Dick Tomanek scores. Bill Tuttle to 2nd.
6–9
▼ 7th
Preston Ward singles on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Bill Tuttle scores. Roger Maris to 2nd.
6–10
▼ 8th
Joe Demaestri singles on a bunt ground ball to pitcher Ryne Duren. Harry Chiti scores. Joe Demaestri to 2nd. Joe Demaestri advances to 2nd, on a fielding error by pitcher Ryne Duren.
6–11
▼ 8th
Bill Tuttle singles on a to right fielder Elston Howard. Joe Demaestri scores.
6–12