▲ 2nd
Rocky Colavito hits a home run (7). Preston Ward scores.
2–0
▼ 2nd
Enos Slaughter hits a home run (3).
2–1
▲ 3rd
Roger Maris triples (1) on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Bobby Avila scores.
3–1
▲ 3rd
Preston Ward doubles (3) on a to left fielder Norm Siebern. Roger Maris scores.
4–1
▼ 4th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (11).
4–2
▼ 4th
Bobby Richardson singles on a ground ball to right fielder Rocky Colavito. Enos Slaughter scores. Norm Siebern to 2nd.
4–3
▼ 5th
Bill Skowron singles on a to left fielder Minnie Minoso. Tony Kubek scores. Mickey Mantle to 3rd. Bill Skowron to 2nd. Bill Skowron advances to 2nd, on a fielding error by left fielder Minnie Minoso.
4–4
▲ 6th
Russ Nixon hits a home run (3).
5–4