▼ 1st
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (9).
0–1
▲ 2nd
Billy Harrell out on a sacrifice fly to right fielder Elston Howard. Rocky Colavito scores.
1–1
▲ 2nd
Dick Tomanek hits a home run (1). Russ Nixon scores.
3–1
▼ 5th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (10). Andy Carey scores. Tony Kubek scores.
3–4
▲ 6th
Preston Ward singles on a ground ball to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Roger Maris scores.
4–4
▼ 7th
Bill Skowron singles on a to left fielder Minnie Minoso. Andy Carey scores. Tony Kubek scores. Bill Skowron out at 2nd on the throw, left fielder Minnie Minoso to second baseman Bobby Avila. Mickey Mantle to 3rd.
4–6
▲ 9th
Bobby Avila reaches on a fielding error by shortstop Tony Kubek. Billy Harrell scores. Larry Doby to 3rd.
5–6