▲ 1st
Roman Mejias hits a home run (2).
1–0
▼ 1st
George Crowe out, second baseman Bill Mazeroski to first baseman Frank Thomas. Alex Grammas scores. Bob Thurman to 3rd. Frank Robinson to 2nd.
1–1
▲ 4th
Frank Thomas hits a home run (21).
2–1
▼ 5th
Wally Post out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Bob Skinner. Alex Grammas scores.
2–2
▼ 6th
Joe Nuxhall out on a sacrifice fly to right fielder Roman Mejias. Don Hoak scores.
2–3
▼ 6th
Alex Grammas doubles (3). Roy McMillan scores.
2–4
▼ 6th
Bob Thurman hits a home run (15). Alex Grammas scores.
2–6
▼ 6th
George Crowe hits a home run (31).
2–7
▲ 7th
Gene Baker doubles (21) on a to left fielder Bob Thurman. Bill Mazeroski scores. Roberto Clemente to 3rd.
3–7
▲ 7th
Jim Pendleton reaches on a fielding error by shortstop Roy McMillan. Roberto Clemente scores.
4–7
▲ 7th
Roman Mejias doubles (7) on a to center fielder Frank Robinson. Gene Baker scores. Jim Pendleton to 3rd.
5–7
▼ 8th
Frank Robinson singles on a to left fielder Bob Skinner. Alex Grammas scores. Bob Thurman to 2nd.
5–8
▼ 8th
George Crowe grounds into a force out, second baseman Bill Mazeroski to shortstop Dick Groat. Bob Thurman scores. Frank Robinson out at 2nd. Throwing error by shortstop Dick Groat.
5–9