▲ 1st
Gene Stephens out, second baseman Bobby Avila to first baseman Vic Wertz. Jim Piersall scores.
1–0
▼ 2nd
Russ Nixon grounds into a double play, first baseman Dick Gernert to shortstop Billy Klaus to pitcher Dave Sisler. Rocky Colavito scores. Roger Maris out at 2nd. Russ Nixon out at 1st.
1–1
▲ 3rd
Jim Piersall hits a home run (9).
2–1
▼ 3rd
Roger Maris singles on a to right fielder Jackie Jensen. Gene Woodling scores. Vic Wertz scores. Rocky Colavito to 3rd.
2–3
▼ 3rd
Russ Nixon singles on a to left fielder Gene Stephens. Rocky Colavito scores. Roger Maris to 2nd.
2–4
▼ 5th
Russ Nixon singles on a to center fielder Jim Piersall. Rocky Colavito scores. Roger Maris to 3rd.
2–5
▼ 5th
Stan Pitula singles on a to third baseman Frank Malzone. Roger Maris scores. Russ Nixon to 3rd. Fielding error by catcher Sammy White.
2–6
▼ 6th
Vic Wertz singles on a to center fielder Jim Piersall. Bobby Avila scores. Gene Woodling to 3rd.
2–7
▼ 6th
Rocky Colavito out on a sacrifice fly to right fielder Jackie Jensen. Gene Woodling scores.
2–8
▲ 7th
Ted Williams hits a home run (25). Sammy White scores.
4–8
▼ 8th
Vic Wertz out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Gene Stephens. Al Smith scores.
4–9
▼ 8th
Russ Nixon walks. Bobby Avila scores. Dick Williams to 3rd. Rocky Colavito to 2nd.
4–10
▼ 8th
George Strickland singles on a to second baseman Billy Consolo. Dick Williams scores. Rocky Colavito scores. Russ Nixon to 2nd.
4–12
▼ 8th
Stan Pitula singles on a to left fielder Gene Stephens. Russ Nixon scores. George Strickland scores. Stan Pitula to 2nd. Stan Pitula advances to 2nd, on a fielding error by left fielder Gene Stephens.
4–14
▼ 8th
Bobby Avila doubles (8) on a to right fielder Jackie Jensen. Stan Pitula scores. Al Smith scores. Bobby Avila scores. Fielding error by right fielder Jackie Jensen.
4–17