▲ 1st
Bill Skowron doubles (8) on a to right fielder Al Kaline. Billy Martin scores. Mickey Mantle to 3rd.
1–0
▲ 2nd
Billy Martin singles on a to center fielder Bill Tuttle. Elston Howard scores. Andy Carey scores. Hank Bauer to 2nd.
3–0
▲ 2nd
Mickey Mantle walks. Hank Bauer scores. Billy Martin to 3rd. Gil McDougald to 2nd.
4–0
▲ 2nd
Bill Skowron grounds into a force out, shortstop Harvey Kuenn to second baseman Jim Brideweser. Billy Martin scores. Gil McDougald scores. Mickey Mantle out at 2nd. Bill Skowron to 1st. Missed catch error by second baseman Jim Brideweser.
6–0
▼ 2nd
Ray Boone hits a sacrifice fly. Fielding error by right fielder Hank Bauer. Jack Phillips scores. Charlie Maxwell to 3rd. Red Wilson to 2nd. Ray Boone to 1st.
6–1
▼ 2nd
Harvey Kuenn grounds into a force out, fielded by second baseman Billy Martin. Charlie Maxwell scores. Red Wilson to 3rd. Ray Boone out at 2nd. Harvey Kuenn to 1st.
6–2
▲ 4th
Mickey Mantle doubles (8) on a to left fielder Charlie Maxwell. Gil McDougald scores.
7–2
▼ 4th
Harvey Kuenn doubles (9) on a to left fielder Bob Cerv. Red Wilson scores. Jim Brady scores.
7–4
▼ 4th
Al Kaline out, third baseman Andy Carey to first baseman Bill Skowron. Harvey Kuenn scores.
7–5
▲ 5th
Hank Bauer hits a home run (9). Andy Carey scores. Tom Carroll scores.
10–5
▲ 5th
Mickey Mantle singles on a to left fielder Charlie Maxwell. Billy Martin scores. Gil McDougald to 2nd.
11–5
▲ 5th
Bill Skowron grounds into a force out, second baseman Jim Brideweser to shortstop Harvey Kuenn. Gil McDougald scores. Mickey Mantle out at 2nd. Bill Skowron to 1st. Missed catch error by shortstop Harvey Kuenn.
12–5
▲ 5th
Elston Howard singles on a to left fielder Charlie Maxwell. Bill Skowron scores.
13–5