▲ 1st
Bob Kennedy singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Minnie Minoso scores. Bob Nieman to 2nd.
1–0
▼ 2nd
Phil Rizzuto walks. Bill Skowron scores. Hank Bauer to 3rd. Billy Martin to 2nd.
1–1
▼ 2nd
Bob Cerv singles on a to left fielder Minnie Minoso. Hank Bauer scores. Billy Martin scores. Phil Rizzuto to 3rd.
1–3
▼ 2nd
Elston Howard hits a home run (10). Phil Rizzuto scores. Bob Cerv scores.
1–6
▲ 3rd
Bob Kennedy singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Minnie Minoso scores. Bob Nieman to 2nd.
2–6
▲ 5th
Chico Carrasquel singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Bob Nieman scores.
3–6
▼ 6th
Gil McDougald grounds into a force out, shortstop Chico Carrasquel to second baseman Nellie Fox. Andy Carey scores. Phil Rizzuto to 3rd. Irv Noren out at 2nd. Gil McDougald to 1st.
3–7
▲ 7th
Bob Kennedy hits a home run (7). Bob Nieman scores.
5–7
▲ 9th
Chico Carrasquel singles on a to left fielder Irv Noren. Bob Kennedy scores. Bobby Adams to 2nd.
6–7
▲ 9th
Walt Dropo singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Bobby Adams scores. Chico Carrasquel scores. Jim Rivera to 3rd.
8–7
▼ 9th
Hank Bauer reaches on a fielding error by left fielder Minnie Minoso. Mickey Mantle scores. Hank Bauer to 2nd.
8–8
▲ 10th
Dixie Howell reaches on a fielding error by first baseman Eddie Robinson. Minnie Minoso scores.
9–8