▲ 1st
Gil McDougald hits a home run (4).
1–0
▼ 1st
Bobby Avila hits a home run (5).
1–1
▼ 1st
Al Rosen singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Larry Doby scores. Al Rosen to 3rd. Throwing error by center fielder Mickey Mantle.
1–2
▲ 2nd
Andy Carey hits a sacrifice bunt. Gene Woodling scores. Irv Noren to 3rd. Andy Carey to 2nd. Throwing error by pitcher Early Wynn.
2–2
▼ 2nd
Jim Hegan hits a home run (4).
2–3
▼ 3rd
Al Rosen grounds into a force out, shortstop Phil Rizzuto to second baseman Gil McDougald. Bobby Avila scores. Larry Doby out at 2nd. Al Rosen to 1st.
2–4
▲ 4th
Andy Carey singles on a to right fielder Dave Philley. Gene Woodling scores. Irv Noren to 3rd.
3–4
▲ 4th
Eddie Robinson out on a sacrifice fly to center fielder Larry Doby. Irv Noren scores.
4–4
▲ 4th
Joe Collins singles on a to left fielder Wally Westlake. Andy Carey scores. Gil McDougald to 3rd.
5–4
▲ 4th
Mickey Mantle doubles (9) on a to right fielder Dave Philley. Gil McDougald scores. Joe Collins to 3rd.
6–4
▼ 5th
Bobby Avila hits a home run (6).
6–5
▲ 7th
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (13).
7–5
▲ 7th
Willy Miranda doubles (1) on a to left fielder Al Smith. Gene Woodling scores. Andy Carey scores.
9–5
▼ 7th
Al Smith hits a home run (6). Jim Hegan scores. Dale Mitchell scores.
9–8
▲ 9th
Johnny Sain grounds into a force out, shortstop George Strickland to second baseman Bobby Avila. Gene Woodling scores. Andy Carey scores. Bob Cerv out at 2nd. Throwing error by second baseman Bobby Avila.
11–8
▼ 9th
Bobby Avila out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Gene Woodling. Jim Hegan scores.
11–9