▲ 1st
Minnie Minoso singles on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Hector Rodriguez scores.
1–0
▼ 1st
Mickey Mantle reaches on a fielder's choice. Loren Babe scores.
1–1
▼ 2nd
Gene Woodling hits a home run (10).
1–2
▲ 3rd
Eddie Robinson singles on a to right fielder Hank Bauer. Hector Rodriguez scores. Nellie Fox to 2nd.
2–2
▲ 3rd
Sam Mele singles on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Nellie Fox scores. Eddie Robinson to 2nd.
3–2
▲ 3rd
Sherm Lollar walks. Eddie Robinson scores. Sam Mele to 3rd. Jim Rivera to 2nd.
4–2
▲ 3rd
Tom Wright grounds into a force out, first baseman Joe Collins to shortstop Phil Rizzuto. Sam Mele scores. Jim Rivera to 3rd. Sherm Lollar out at 2nd. Tom Wright to 1st.
5–2
▲ 3rd
Saul Rogovin singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Jim Rivera scores. Willy Miranda to 2nd.
6–2
▲ 3rd
Hector Rodriguez singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Willy Miranda scores. Saul Rogovin out at 3rd on the throw, center fielder Mickey Mantle to shortstop Phil Rizzuto to first baseman Joe Collins to third baseman Loren Babe.
7–2
▲ 4th
Jim Rivera singles on a to center fielder Mickey Mantle. Nellie Fox scores. Minnie Minoso scores. Sam Mele to 2nd.
9–2
▲ 6th
Sherm Lollar singles on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Jim Rivera scores.
10–2
▲ 8th
Sam Mele hits a home run (12). Eddie Robinson scores.
12–2
▼ 9th
Hank Bauer flies out to left fielder Minnie Minoso. Mickey Mantle scores.
12–3