▲ 1st
Eddie Robinson triples (3) on a to right fielder Mickey Mantle. Minnie Minoso scores.
1–0
▼ 1st
Hank Bauer singles. Mickey Mantle scores.
1–1
▼ 1st
Yogi Berra hits a home run (10). Hank Bauer scores. Jackie Jensen scores.
1–4
▼ 1st
Mickey Mantle walks. Johnny Mize scores. Jerry Coleman to 3rd. Stubby Overmire to 2nd.
1–5
▲ 3rd
Don Lenhardt doubles (6). Bob Dillinger scores. Nellie Fox scores. Eddie Robinson to 3rd.
3–5
▲ 3rd
Chico Carrasquel singles. Eddie Robinson scores. Don Lenhardt scores. Jim Busby to 2nd.
5–5
▲ 3rd
Lou Kretlow singles. Jim Busby scores. Chico Carrasquel to 2nd.
6–5
▼ 3rd
Gene Woodling singles. Bobby Brown scores. Jerry Coleman to 2nd.
6–6
▼ 3rd
Mickey Mantle hits a home run (5). Jerry Coleman scores. Gene Woodling scores.
6–9
▲ 5th
Bud Stewart out to right fielder Mickey Mantle. Phil Masi scores.
7–9
▲ 5th
Lou Kretlow reaches on a fielding error by pitcher Jack Kramer. Chico Carrasquel scores. Lou Kretlow to 2nd. Throwing error by pitcher Jack Kramer.
8–9
▲ 6th
Jim Busby singles. Eddie Robinson scores. Phil Masi to 2nd.
9–9
▼ 6th
Bobby Brown singles. Joe Collins scores.
9–10
▼ 6th
Phil Rizzuto singles on a to center fielder Jim Busby. Gene Woodling scores. Mickey Mantle to 2nd.
9–11