▲ 1st
Gil McDougald out, shortstop Chico Carrasquel to first baseman Eddie Robinson. Mickey Mantle scores.
1–0
▼ 2nd
Phil Masi singles on a to pitcher Spec Shea. Bud Stewart scores.
1–1
▲ 4th
Hank Bauer singles on a to right fielder Minnie Minoso. Phil Rizzuto scores. Gil McDougald to 2nd.
2–1
▲ 4th
Johnny Mize singles on a to left fielder Bud Stewart. Gil McDougald scores. Hank Bauer to 2nd.
3–1
▲ 4th
Jerry Coleman singles on a to center fielder Jim Busby. Hank Bauer scores. Johnny Mize to 2nd.
4–1
▲ 4th
Spec Shea grounds into a force out, shortstop Chico Carrasquel to second baseman Nellie Fox. Johnny Mize scores. Jerry Coleman to 3rd. Charles Silvera out at 2nd. Spec Shea to 1st.
5–1
▼ 4th
Billy Pierce singles on a to left fielder Hank Bauer. Jim Busby scores.
5–2
▲ 5th
Gil McDougald doubles (7) on a to left fielder Bud Stewart. Phil Rizzuto scores.
6–2
▼ 5th
Eddie Robinson singles on a to left fielder Gene Woodling. Nellie Fox scores. Minnie Minoso to 3rd.
6–3
▼ 5th
Don Lenhardt out to left fielder Gene Woodling. Minnie Minoso scores.
6–4
▲ 6th
Phil Rizzuto singles on a bunt ground ball to first baseman Eddie Robinson. Charles Silvera scores. Tommy Byrne to 2nd.
7–4
▲ 6th
Gil McDougald walks.
8–4
▲ 6th
Gene Woodling out to center fielder Jim Busby. Phil Rizzuto scores.
9–4
▲ 8th
Jerry Coleman reaches on a fielder's choice, fielded by shortstop Chico Carrasquel. Gene Woodling scores. Jackie Jensen to 3rd. Johnny Hopp to 2nd.
10–4
▼ 8th
Bob Dillinger singles on a to third baseman Gil McDougald. Chico Carrasquel scores. Phil Masi to 3rd. Joe Erautt to 2nd.
10–5